Scholarly record
ZARATHUSTRA AT THE MARKETPLACE. NIETZSCHE AND THE CITY OF MEN
Abstract
In the labyrinth of the Nietzschean interpretations, what is missing is a chapter which investigates Nietzsche's critique of the city of men. This is what the following research sets out to do: to reconstruct through first-hand reading of the Nietzschean texts and the little bibliography on the topic Nietzsche's reflections on the everyday rationale of city life. A posthumous note dating back to his early years suggests that Nietzsche had planned a work dedicated to the metropolis as part of the incomplete project of the Unzeitgemässe Betrachtungen. Although the content of this never-realised work is left to speculation, precious hints on the theme of the city are scattered around his published works and the posthumous fragments. What we are certain of is that Nietzsche observes city life with great care and reflects on living together in a very sensitive way, providing a rich and lively "phenomenological cross section" of the public dimension of modern people. Also sprach Zarathustra is the reference text. The reason is that Zarathustra's narrative is set in those very places which become the protagonists of the Nietzschean reflections: the square, the houses, the market. In one word: the city. Public and private spaces which are no longer in the background but rather reflect the thoughts of the people who inhabit them, thus becoming genuine "philosophical places". Human places which manifest the decadence of nineteenth-century people. The square is thus synonymous with conformism and massification, the houses shed light on the moral pettiness of people, the marketplace becomes the mouthpiece of a hypocritical and petty public life. Nietzsche seems to be well aware that the experience of modernity fully corresponds to the experience of the city. The city is the fascinating stage for the mise-en-scene of modern mankind. A mediocre and vice-ridden mankind, from which one might want to escape altogether. So far removed from the Übermensch preached by Zarathustra, but at once so close to us citizens of the twenty-first century. Helpful to make us reflect on our everyday living together and, from time to time, to call it into question.
Publication Impact Profile
Publication details
References133
B. Himmelmann, Geprobte Göttlichkeit, in AA.VV., Nietzsches «Also sprach Zarathustra», Schwabe, Basel 2001, p. 148.
K. Anders, Nietzsche und der Moloch Stadt, in AA.VV., Versuchendes Denken I, Humboldt-Universität, Berlin 1994, p. 67;
C.G. Jung, Nietzsche’s Zarathustra, Princeton University, Princeton 1988, I, p. 48;
A. Honneth, Das Paradox des Augenblicks, Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg 2004, p. 147.
C. Türcke, Der tolle Mensch, Fischer, Frankfurt a.M. 1989, p. 16;
C. Windgätter, Zarathustras Vorrede, in «Zeitenwende - Wertewende», Akademie, Berlin 2001, p. 300.
M. Romanini, Il prologo di “Così parlò Zarathustra”, La Nuova Foglio, Pollenza 1975, p. 71.
F. Nietzsche, Also sprach Zarathustra, De Gruyter, Berlin 1968, Vorrede, § 3.
M. Romanini, Il prologo, p. 69.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, III, Von der verkleinernden Tugend, § 3.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, Vorrede, § 3, § 8;
AA.VV., Il superuomo e i suoi simboli nelle letterature moderne, La Nuova Italia, Firenze 1971, I, p. 120;
M. Romanini, Il prologo, p. 69.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, Vorrede, § 6;
Id., Schopenhauer als Erzieher, De Gruyter, Berlin - New York 1972, § 5;
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1879-1881, 1 [55], 1 [71];
R. Garofalo, Idee sociologiche e politiche di Dante, Nietzsche e Tolstoi, Reber, Palermo 1907, pp. 99, 112-113;
W. Kunicki, Über den Seiltänzer, in AA.VV., Nietzsche und Schopenhauer, Leipziger Universität, Leipzig 2006, pp. 223-235.
F. Nietzsche, Die fröhliche Wissenschaft, De Gruyter, Berlin - New York 1973, § 283;
Id., Zarathustra, Vorrede, § 6.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, Vorrede, § 3;
M. Romanini, Il prologo, p. 69.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, Vorrede, § 5;
Id., Zarathustra, III, Von der verkleinernden Tugend, § 3;
F. Ferrante, Come parlò Zarathustra?, La città del sole, Napoli 1996, pp. 20, 22;
J. Pestlin, „In den Städten ist schlecht zu leben“, in AA.VV., Versuchendes Denken, pp. 78-79;
R. Reschke, Denkumbrüche mit Nietzsche, Akademie, Berlin 2000, pp. 37-38.
F. Nietzsche, Die fröhliche Wissenschaft, § 125.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, Vorrede, §§ 6-9;
Id., Zarathustra, II, Von den Tugendhaften;
Id., Zarathustra, III, Von den alten und neuen Tafeln, § 26;
Id., Die fröhliche Wissenschaft, § 2;
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1879-1881, 6 [176];
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1882-1884, 22 [1];
R. Reschke, Denkumbrüche, p. 39;
A. Pieper, „Ein Seil Geknüpft zwischen Tier und Übermensch“, Klett-Cotta, Stuttgart 1990, p. 81;
cfr. A. Messer, Erläuterungen zu Nietzsches Zarathustra, Strecker & Schröder, Stuttgart 1922, pp. 17-20;
cfr. G. Naumann, Zarathustra-Commentar, Haessel, Leipzig 1899-1901, I, pp. 109-110;
cfr. G. Whitlock, Returning to Sils-Maria, Lang, New York 1990, pp. 221-222;
cfr. L. Lampert, Nietzsche’s Teaching, Yale University, New Haven - London 1986, pp. 208-209;
cfr. A. Honneth, Das Paradox, pp. 287-293.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, III, Von der verkleinernden Tugend, § 1;
Id., Jenseits von Gut und Böse, De Gruyter, Berlin 1968, § 30;
L. Bonesio, La “saggezza selvatica” di Zarathustra, in «La società degli individui», 10 (2001), p. 60;
S. Giametta, Commento allo “Zarathustra”, Mondadori, Milano 1996, pp. 171-172;
cfr. G. Naumann, Zarathustra, III, pp. 42-43.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, III, Von der verkleinernden Tugend, §§ 2-3;
Id., David Strauss, De Gruyter, Berlin - New York 1972, § 9;
Id., Die fröhliche Wissenschaft, § 368;
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1882-1884, 17 [13].
F. Nietzsche, Schopenhauer, § 1;
Id., Zarathustra, Vorrede, § 4.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, Vorrede, § 3;
Id., Die fröhliche Wissenschaft, § 125;
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1882-1884, 13 [1];
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1884-1885, 29 [56];
R. Reschke, Denkumbrüche, pp. 40-41;
AA.VV., Il superuomo, II, p. 156;
P. Gasser, Leseversuche zum metaphorischen Diskurs in Nietzsches „Also sprach Zarathustra“, Lang, Berlin 1993, p. 17;
A. Pieper, Ein Seil, p. 231;
G. Naumann, Zarathustra, I, p. 169;
V. Vivarelli, Nietzsche und Emerson, in «Nietzsche Studien», 16 (1987), p. 244;
M.C. Fornari, La morale evolutiva del gregge, ETS, Pisa 2006, p. 292;
cfr. C. Türcke, Der tolle Mensch, pp. 16-25;
U. Marti, „Der grosse Pöbel- und Sklavenaufstand“, Metzler, Stuttgart 1993, p. 202.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, I, Von den Fliegen des Marktes;
G. Naumann, Zarathustra, I, p. 169.
A. Pieper, Ein Seil, pp. 231-232.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, I, Von den Fliegen des Marktes;
Id., Zarathustra, II, Das Kind mit dem Spiegel;
Id., Zarathustra, III, Die Heimkehr;
Id., Morgenröthe, De Gruyter, New York - Berlin 1971, § 423;
Id., Die fröhliche Wissenschaft, § 331, § 377;
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1882-1884, 4 [13], 4 [84], 18 [30];
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1881-1882, 14 [12], 14 [25];
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1884-1885, 37 [14];
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1885-1887, 2 [183];
Id., Zur Genealogie der Moral, De Gruyter, Berlin 1968, III, § 26;
Id., Jenseits von Gut und Böse, § 282;
Id., Briefwechsel, II/4, 3 November 1874, De Gruyter, Berlin - New York 1975;
M.C. Fornari, La morale, p. 294;
G. Pasqualotto, Commento a Così parlò Zarathustra, BUR, Milano 1985, pp. 422-423;
L. Arcella, L’innocenza di Zarathustra, Mimesis, Milano 2010, p. 129;
U. Marti, Der grosse Pöbel, p. 204;
J. Pestlin, In den Städten, p. 79;
cfr. L. Lampert, Nietzsche, pp. 56-57;
cfr. G. Whitlock, Returning, pp. 83-84;
cfr. A. Pieper, Ein Seil, pp. 232-235;
cfr. H. Weichelt, Zarathustra, pp. 32-34;
cfr. G. Naumann, Zarathustra, I, pp. 169-172;
cfr. C.G. Jung, Nietzsche, I, pp. 601-606.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, I, Von den Fliegen des Marktes;
Id., Zarathustra, II, Von den Priestern;
Id., Zarathustra, III, Die Heimkehr;
Id., Zarathustra, III, Von der verkleinernden Tugend, § 2;
Id., Zarathustra, IV, Vom höheren Menschen, § 3;
Id., Menschliches, Allzumenschliches, De Gruyter, Berlin 1967, II, Vermischte Meinungen und Sprüche, § 368;
Id., Morgenröthe, § 228, § 435, § 506;
Id., Die fröhliche Wissenschaft, § 218;
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1882-1884, 4 [234], 5 [1] 260;
cfr. A. Negri, Il superuomo antieroe, SEAM, Formello 2001, pp. 65-76;
cfr. A. Pieper, Ein Seil, pp. 235-244;
cfr. H. Weichelt, Zarathustra, pp. 34-36;
cfr. G. Naumann, Zarathustra, I, pp. 172-174;
cfr. C.G. Jung, Nietzsche, I, pp. 606-618.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, IV, Vom höheren Menschen, § 1.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, IV, Gespräch mit den Königen, § 1;
Id., Zarathustra, Vom höheren Menschen, § 8;
Id., Jenseits von Gut und Böse, § 25;
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1884, 25 [84];
Id., Nachgelassene Fragmente, 1884-1885, 34 [2];
cfr. H. Weichelt, Zarathustra, pp. 176-178;
cfr. G. Naumann, Zarathustra, IV, pp. 24-34.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, I, Von der schenkenden Tugend, § 1;
Id., Zarathustra, III, Von den Abtrünnigen, § 2;
Id., Zarathustra, III, Die Heimkehr;
Id., Zarathustra, II, Das Kind mit dem Spiegel;
Id., Zarathustra, Vorrede, § 1;
Id., Vom Nutzen und Nachteil der Historie für das Leben, De Gruyter, Berlin - New York 1972, § 4;
cfr. C. Resta, Nietzsche e la montagna, in AA.VV., Oltre le vette, Il Poligrafo, Padova 2000, pp. 33-58.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, II, Von den Mitleidigen;
Id., Zarathustra, Vorrede, § 10;
Id., Zarathustra, III, Von den Abtrünnigen, § 2;
Id., Menschliches, Allzumenschliches, II, Vermischte Meinungen und Sprüche, § 348.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, III, Auf dem Oelbergen.
F. Nietzsche, Ecce homo, De Gruyter, Berlin 1969, § 8.
F. Nietzsche, Jenseits von Gut und Böse, § 257, § 271, § 284;
Id., Der Antichrist, De Gruyter, Berlin 1969, § 1.
F. Nietzsche, Zarathustra, III, Die Heimkehr;
Id., Zarathustra, III, Der Genesende, § 2;
Id., Zur Genealogie, II, § 24.
F. Nietzsche, Ecce homo, § 8;
R. Escobar, Nietzsche e il tragico, Il Formichiere, Milano 1980, pp. 72-73.
View or Download full articleAccess options
SWS access login
Login as SWS Scientific CommitteeLogin as SWS Scientific PartnerLogin as SWS AuthorAuthors and approved SWS contributors will read and export their own linked papers after identity matching by SWS profile, email and SGEM GlobalID.
For librarian assistance: [email protected]
Purchase Instant Access
- Article can be downloaded after successful payment.
- Article may be used according to SWS library access terms.
- Article cannot be redistributed.
