Scholarly record
THE COVID PANDEMIC AND THE ECONOMIC MIGRATION OF DOCTORS THE CASE OF THE REPUBLIC CROATIA
Abstract
Human capital is the primary driver of change in the modern knowledge society. The migration of healthcare workers is a "brain drain" of highly qualified individuals. Healthcare workers are currently among the most sought-after and mobile occupations in the EU. The global trend of open borders and free movement of goods, people and capital is an important determinant of growth and development, which developed countries have already recognized at the expense of less developed ones. The aim of this paper is to highlight the importance of the volume of migration, which is not insignificant, and the long-term consequences are negative for society and the economy. There are numerous reasons for economically motivated migration, and there are three main groups of problems that need to be solved urgently in order to stop further emigration. The departure was primarily motivated by problems caused by general social and political circumstances, as well as dissatisfaction with the general state and socio-political climate in the country. Reasons for dissatisfaction are low wages and living standards, dissatisfaction with the organization and management of the state, hopelessness and deterioration of regions, cities, society and people, corruption and crime, religious intolerance and nationalism in the absence of positive changes in the state. An increasing number of young people are leaving their homelands in search of a "better life", and without them the progress of the country is impossible. What is worrying is the youthful pessimism that already prevails in the attitudes of young people towards issues of political and economic progress and social development. Croatia is currently one of the three EU countries with the largest number of emigrating healthcare workers. In its Report for Croatia for 2018, the European Commission stated that spending on healthcare in Croatia is stagnating, while spending across the EU is growing [2]. Healthcare expenditures in Croatia were among the lowest in the European Union; they amounted to only 760 euros per inhabitant in 2015 and are lower only in Romania, Latvia and Bulgaria. Furthermore, total healthcare spending in Croatia has remained stable since 2011, and the vast majority of EU member states have been spending more on healthcare in recent years, which is usually attributed to increasing costs for technological advances in medicine and an aging population. Healthcare is still underfunded and over-indebted. Since regular sources of financing are not sufficient to cover all costs, the system accumulates outstanding debts that are eventually settled with one-time transfers from the state budget. The scientific contribution of this work is to point out the shortcomings in the system and offer possible solutions.
Publication Impact Profile
Publication details
References26
Adamovic, M., Meznaric, S.,Potential and actual "outflow" of young scientists from of Croatia: empirical research. Review of Sociology XXXIV (3-4): pp 143– 160. 2003, available at https://hrcak.srce.hr/file/22174; ISSN 0350-154X (Tisak); ISSN 1846-7954 (Online); DOI: 10.5613/rzs
Europska Komisija (2018), Report for Croatia with a detailed review on the prevention and correction of macroeconomic imbalances
Europsko vijece, COVID 19: EU public health response, 2020, available at https://www.consilium.europa.eu/hr/policies/coronavirus/covid-19-public-health/
EU4Health programme (2020), available at https://ec.europa.eu/health/sites/health/files/funding/docs/eu4health_factsheet_en.pdf
Hrvatski zavod za statistiku (2019), Average salary for health care activities/gross and gross 2013-2018
Hrvatski zavod za zaposljavanje (2021), Statistika on-line available at https://statistika.hzz.hr//
Hrvatska lijecnika komora HLK (2020), Press release - Report for the public on the departure of doctors abroad 2013-2019
Hrvatska lijecnika komora HLK (2017), Press release - The HLK project for the professional training of general and family medicine doctors through the Ministry of Health secured HRK 30 million from EU funds, available at https://www.hlk.hr/EasyEdit/UserFiles/priop%C4%87enja/priopcenje-projektu-hlk-aosigurano-30-milijuna-kuna.pdf
Hrvatska udruge poslodavaca HUP (2021), One in five hospitals stopped paying for already delivered goods in the last 2 months, available at https://www.hup.hr/svaka-petabolnica-prestala-s-placanjem-vec-isporucene-robe-posljednja-2-mjeseca--dugoviprema-veledrogerijama-zadnjem-lancu-nelikvidnost-u-hrvatskoj-dosegnuli-alarmantnurazinu.aspx
Global Wage Report (2015), ILO
Gruber, E.; Sarajlic Vukovic, I.; Musovic, M.; Moravek, D.; Starcevic, B., Martic Biocina, S. and Knez R., Migration of Croatian doctors in a global context, Medicina Fluminensis: Medicina Fluminensis, Vol. 56 No. 2, 2020.; ISSN 1847-6864 (Tisak); ISSN 1848-820X (Online); DOI: 10.21860/medflum2020_237296
IOM World Migration Report 2020. Geneva, available at https://publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/wmr_2020.pdf
Juresko, G., Disturbance in the appointment. Jutarnji list - Morning paper, September 12, 2020, available at https://www.jutarnji.hr/vijesti/hrvatska/hoce-li-namse-zbog-ogranicene-zdravstvene-uslugepovecati-smrtnost-od-primjerice-raka-15018676
Juric, T., The most expensive doctor and nurse are those who are not there. Medix, 26(144/145) pp 30-33, 2020
Kralj, V., Brkic Bilos, I., Coric, T., Silobrcic Radic, M., Sekerij M., Chronic noncommunicable diseases - the burden of diseases of the population of Croatia, Cardiologia Croatica, 2015; ISSN 1848-543X (print), ISSN 1848-5448 (online); DOI: 10.15836/ccar.2015.167
Lijecnike novine (2019). Gazette of the Croatian Medical Chamber, No. 184; ISSN 1333-2775
Lider, HLK: As many as 67% of doctors usually work overtime, 2019. available at https://lider.media/poslovna-scena/hrvatska/hlk-cak-67-posto-lijecnika-uobicajeno-radiprekovremeno-128477
Lider, The new Law on Foreigners was passed, 2020. available at https://lider.media/poslovna-scena/hrvatska/izglasan-novi-zakon-o-strancima-ukidajuse-kvote-za-zaposljavanje-134211
MojaPlaca (2020). Salary Calculator, available at https://www.mojaplaca.hr/placa/medicina-i-socijalna-skrb/lijecnik
Sljivak, M., How many doctors left the largest Croatian hospitals in 5 years, 2018, www.index.hr available at https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/doznajemo-koliko-jelijecnika-u-5-godina-otislo-iz-najvecih-hrvatskih-bolnica/1022438.aspx
Sljivak, M., Soon, covid certificates will be, 2021, www.index.hr, available on https://www.index.hr/vijesti/clanak/uskoro-krecu-covidpotvrde-evo-tko-se-u-zdravstvunajvise-cijepi-a-tko-najmanje/2305322.aspx
Penic, G., The number of employees in the state and public administration continues to grow, the state employs six people a day, Jutranji list - Morning paper, 4 March 2020. available at https://www.jutarnji.hr/vijesti/hrvatska/broj-zaposlenih-u-drzavnoj-i-javnojupravi-i-dalje-raste-drzava-dnevno-zaposljava-sest-osoba/10046389/
Petric, I., Dorrier Health: What's in store for the system once this pandemic is over, 2020, available at https://korona.net.hr/nema-kategorije/dossier-zdravstvo-sto-cekasustav-jednom-kada-ova-pandemija-zavrsi/
Pravilnik o specijastickom usavrsavanju doktora medicine NN 100/2011, 133/2011, 54/2012, 49/2013, 139/2014, 82/2015, 116/2015, 62/2016, 69/2016, 6/2017
Slobodna Dalmacija Chamber and Trade Union: There is a shortage of 4,500 nurses and technicians in hospitals. These figures are not from yesterday, we have been warning about the same problems for years, 2020, available at https://slobodnadalmacija.hr/vijesti/hrvatska/komora-i-sindikat-u-bolnicama-nedostaje- 4500-medicinskih-sestara-i-tehnicara-ove-brojke-nisu-od-jucer-godinamaupozoravamo-na-iste-probleme-1045073
World Health Organization WHO (2006). Working Together for Health: The World Heath Report, Geneva, xxvi, 209 p; ISBN 9241563176, 9789241563178. https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/43432
View or Download full articleAccess options
SWS access login
Login as SWS Scientific CommitteeLogin as SWS Scientific PartnerLogin as SWS AuthorAuthors and approved SWS contributors will read and export their own linked papers after identity matching by SWS profile, email and SGEM GlobalID.
For librarian assistance: [email protected]
Purchase Instant Access
- Article can be downloaded after successful payment.
- Article may be used according to SWS library access terms.
- Article cannot be redistributed.